Training with dog training treats

Dog Training Treats - Choosing the Best Reward for Your Pup

Written by: Henry F.

|

Time to read 5 min

Why the Right Dog Training Treats Matter

Using the right dog training treats makes training easier and more effective. High-value dog training treats keep dogs engaged, while everyday dog training treats help reinforce regular behaviours. Choosing natural, healthy options ensures your pup gets the best nutrition while learning.

Table of contents

Why the Right Dog Training Treats Matter Comparing Different Dog Training Treats Avoid Highly Processed Dog Training Treats How to Use Dog Training Treats Effectively Alfie’s Treatos - Perfect Dog Training Treats Choosing the Best Dog Training Treats

The best dog training treats are tasty, natural, and easy to use. They should be:

  • High-value for tough training sessions – Strong-smelling, flavorful treats like fish-based options keep dogs focused.

  • Healthy and natural – Avoid artificial fillers and preservatives. Single-ingredient treats provide essential nutrients.

  • Easy to handle – Small, breakable dog training treats are ideal for quick reinforcement without overfeeding.

Comparing Different Dog Training Treats

Kibble - Low Value

For everyday reinforcement, kibble can be a great dog training treat alternative to high-value treats. It provides a consistent, low-calorie reward and helps prevent overfeeding. While kibble may not be as exciting as fresh meat or seafood treats, it can be effective for maintaining learned behaviors.


By reserving high-value treats like sardines and salmon skin for challenging tasks, you create a stronger training hierarchy that keeps your dog motivated.


Dehydrated Meat Treats - Medium Value 

Dehydrated meat treats provide a balanced dog training treat option for everyday training. They are high in protein , palatable, and less messy than fish-based treats . While they may not have the same intense aroma as sardines or salmon skin, they are still an effective motivator for dogs that respond well to meaty flavors.


Their dry, easy-to-handle texture makes them a practical choice for both indoor and outdoor training. for regular reinforcement. They are less messy than fish treats but still high in protein and is an easy to carry dog training treat.

puppy with kibble which is a low value dog training treat

Prawn & Mussels - Higher Value 

Prawn and mussels are low-oil, high-protein dog training treats that are easy to break into small pieces, making them a great option for frequent rewards.


Unlike fish-based treats, they are less greasy, which makes them ideal for carrying in a treat pouch for outdoor training sessions. Their light, crunchy texture makes them a convenient and effective reinforcement option. that is easy to break into small pieces. These dog training treats are great for outdoor training where messiness is a concern.


Sardines & Salmon Skin - Very High Value 

Sardines and salmon skin are super high-value dog training treats, making them ideal for teaching difficult behaviors or reinforcing commands in challenging environments.


Their strong aroma and rich taste grab a dog's attention immediately. However, these treats are oilier due to the Omega-3 content and higher calories, so they should be used for behaviors that are hard to reinforce. 

Avoid Highly Processed Dog Training Treats

Artificial Preservatives (BHA, BHT, Ethoxyquin)

Added Sugars & Salt

Meat By-Products & Fillers

Artificial Flavours & Colours

Many commercial dog training treats contain artificial flavors, preservatives, and fillers that offer little nutritional value. These additives can be harmful over time, potentially causing allergic reactions, skin issues, and digestive discomfort in dogs. Highly processed treats may include excessive salt, sugar, and synthetic ingredients that can lead to weight gain and long-term health problems such as obesity, diabetes, and kidney strain.


Additionally, many artificial ingredients are used to enhance taste and prolong shelf life rather than providing actual nutritional benefits. Using natural, minimally processed treats ensures that your dog stays healthy while reinforcing good behavior. Opting for high-quality, single-ingredient dog training treats not only supports better digestion but also contributes to a shinier coat, stronger joints, and overall well-being.

Processed treats are not good dog training treats

How to Use Dog Training Treats Effectively

Not all training requires the highest-value dog training treats. Use kibble for reinforcing everyday behaviors, and reserve premium dog training treats for harder tasks. Break larger treats into smaller pieces to manage calories while keeping your dog motivated.

  • Basic Training  - Use kibble or low-value dog training treats for reinforcing simple commands.

  • Difficult Training  - For complex behaviors or distractions, opt for sardines or salmon skin dog training treats to maximize motivation.

  • Outdoor Training  - Choose prawn or mussels for their low oil content and ease of handling.

  • Managing Calories  - Break dog training treats into small portions to control intake without reducing effectiveness.

This is Alfie demonstrating impressive training skills by performing spins, sitting, lying down, and showcasing exceptional impulse control. He patiently waits for the "wait" command before enjoying his mussel reward.

Alfie’s Treatos - Perfect Dog Training Treats

At Alfie’s Treatos, we offer natural, single-ingredient seafood dog training treats that make training effective and rewarding:

  • Sardines & Salmon Skin – High-value, best for tough training sessions.

  • Prawn & Mussels – Easy to break, low oil, perfect for outdoor training.

If you want healthy, natural, and effective dog training treats, try Alfie’s Treatos today!

Why choose seafood dog treats over beef or chicken?

Seafood dog treats are packed with Omega-3 and Omega-6 fatty acids, supporting healthy skin, a shiny coat, and strong joints - benefits often missing in beef or chicken treats.

Why choose Australian and New Zealand seafood?

Seafood from Australia and New Zealand is celebrated for its quality and sustainability. Pristine waters and strict regulations guarantee low-pollutant, delicious treats your dog will adore.

Why dehydrated and not freeze dried?

Freeze-drying can damage cells through ice crystal formation. Our gentle dehydration process preserves nutrients, keeping our treats naturally wholesome and nutritious.

What sets our seafood dog treats apart from the rest?

We treat our dog to the same quality we’d eat ourselves. That’s why our treats are human-grade and made to the highest standards.

Choosing the Best Dog Training Treats

Choosing the right dog training treats helps improve focus, engagement, and learning.

High-value treats like sardines and salmon skin work best for challenging training tasks.

Low-oil dog training treats like prawn and mussels are great for outdoor training due to easy handling.

Dehydrated meat treats provide a balanced, everyday dog training treat option with minimal mess.

Avoid highly processed treats with artificial fillers, preservatives, and excessive salt or sugar.

Kibble can be used for regular reinforcement, reserving premium treats for tougher behaviours.

Break treats into small pieces to manage calorie intake while maintaining motivation.

Choosing the right dog training treats makes a big difference in training success. High-value, natural options work best for difficult tasks, while low-oil, easy-to-carry treats are perfect for outdoor or routine training. By using the right treats at the right time, you keep your dog engaged while managing their health.


Want to improve your training sessions? Explore our range of premium dog training treats today!

Shop Now
Pinterest
Henry - Owner of Alfie

Henry F.

Henry is the founder of Alfie’s Treatos, a premium Australian brand specializing in single-ingredient seafood dog treats. Inspired by his English Cocker Spaniel, Alfie, he crafts nutritious, air-dried treats rich in Omega-3 using sustainably sourced Australian and New Zealand seafood. With a background in business and finance, Henry is passionate about providing healthier, additive-free alternatives for dogs while expanding Alfie’s Treatos across wholesale, retail, and international markets.


← Go back